Mcwilliam's Mount Pleasant Elizabeth Semillon 2007, Hunter Valley

Semillon Semillon
New South Wales, Australia

$15.75 (724492)

  • None
     
  • Drink Now Or Cellar
  • 9090

90 pts
7
November 22, 2014

Critic Reviews (5)

Rhys Pender, MW
Rhys Pender, MW

Honey, nut, butter and stone fruit with tropical fruit and toast notes. The palate is dry, crisp and fresh with...

Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
  • Thumbs-up (1)
  • Thumbs-down (0)
Sara d'Amato
Sara d'Amato

This aged semillon is showing lovely nuttiness, still vibrant acids and a slightly creamy finish. Its light golden...

Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)
John Szabo, MS
John Szabo, MS

An arch-classic Hunter semillon, drinking beautifully now. And what a spectacular value. This is all white toast with...

Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)
Julian Hitner
Julian Hitner

Representing astonishing value for money, the 2007 Mount Pleasant Elizabeth Semillon is an unblemished gem. Light...

Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)
Michael Godel
Michael Godel

The 2007 is another fascinating study in Hunter Valley Sémillon. Like the '06, egressing secondary notes have...

Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
Sign In to see Critic Reviews. Not a Member? Please Sign Up.
  • Thumbs-up (1)
  • Thumbs-down (0)

Community Reviews (2)

Bruce Hill
Bruce Hill

Stunning wine. Very serious. Not for the fainthearted. Reminded me of Tondonia or Musar. Very long, intense and complex. Ordered a case.

9595
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)
Blair WineLover
Blair WineLover

This wine did not work for me at all. It tastes like a not so good heavily oaked chardonnay. Michael Godel uses words like stenosis and petrol. I should have listened to him.

8787
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)