Roche De Bellene Volnay Les Pitures 1er Cru 2008, Ac

Pinot Noir Pinot Noir
Burgundy, France

$29.95 (241083)

  • None
     
  • Cellar
  • 4.74.7

4.7/5
7
Nov 12, 2011

Critic Reviews (4)

You must Sign Up to see the critic reviews. Find Out More.

Community Reviews (3)

Andrew Hunter
Andrew Hunter

Very tight nose opened to black cherry and herbs. I tasted this blind with a bunch of other less pricey pinots and this did not stand out. It's clear that this is a well made wine but it's very tight now, almost dead. There's elegance i suppose and perhaps some complexity that may come out with time, but very little going on right now. I highly suspect that the label and pedigree have inflated the rating of this wine. The emperor is missing some clothes. It's a good wine, but you can get more for much less.

4.54.5
  • Thumbs-up (1)
  • Thumbs-down (0)

Visit my website torontowineguy.blogspot.com/
Edward Rasiulis
Edward Rasiulis

Medium ruby in colour with a medium intense nose.

Positives: An elegant Pinot showing some spruce, cranberry, sour cherry, raspberry, rhubarb & light earthiness. Light to medium body, medium minus tannins, good acidity & medium+ length.

Negatives: A touch too sour on the finish.

Drink now & a very food friendly wine that you can match with game fowl.

Tasted: 16 Sept 12

Score: 8.5+/10, Value: 8.5+/10, Total: 17.5/20

Out of 5 stars, I rated this wine: 3.5

4.44.4
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)

Visit my website www.twilightwines.com
Wine 4  Me
Wine 4 Me

Light-bodied, with lean cranberry/tart cherry flavours. This is tight and firm but finishes with very sour notes and high acidity. For me, a completely joyless wine at the present. maybe time will improve this but I wouldn't bet on it. Really disappointing given the glowing reviews. Tasted Sept 2013.

4.04.0
  • Thumbs-up (0)
  • Thumbs-down (0)