Not sure what all the controversy is about...Terrible score from Lawrason, average from the rest of the WA crew... I found nothing terribly wrong here. The nose bursts with bright ripe cherries and vanilla with hints of smoke. The palate is juicy and delicious with bright cherry, cran-raspberry and vanilla. Short but juicy finish. You can purchase this bottle for $15 in the USA, so my only complaint is the LCBO mark up.